The night Jimmy Buffett got stuck on the Seven Mile Bridge...

In partnership with

Florida Keys Road Trip | August 3, 2026

Hey Keys lovers! This week, we're taking a trip back to 1972 to uncover the hidden Key West spots that shaped Jimmy Buffett's early career — including the exact night he debuted "Margaritaville." Plus: a massive coral rescue operation, the opening of regular lobster season, and the fascinating story of how a hurricane-flooded railroad quarry became one of the world's oldest marine parks.

Was this forwarded to you? Sign up here to get on Keys Time every week — it's free!

❓ Keys Trivia

In 1972, Key West buried a time capsule to celebrate the island's 150th birthday. What happened when they tried to find it 50 years later?

Answer at the bottom of the newsletter.

📣 The Mile Marker Roundup

🪸 Mote Marine Rescues Thousands of Corals
With ocean temperatures pushing past 87°F, Mote Marine Laboratory has launched a massive Keys-wide effort to rescue thousands of endangered corals from offshore nurseries. The corals are being safeguarded in land-based facilities to protect them from heat stress and bleaching. Read more →

🎉 28th Annual Key West Lobsterfest
The five-day festival celebrating the opening of Florida's regular spiny lobster season returns August 5-9. Events include lobster boils, pool parties, and a massive Duval Street fair on August 8 featuring live music and a contest for the best lobster dish on the island. Read more →

🚒 Sugarloaf Fire Station Relocated
Monroe County Fire Rescue has temporarily relocated personnel from Station 10 in Sugarloaf Key to neighboring stations while the county works to rebuild the facility. Read more →

🌴 Partner Spotlight

Find Your Perfect Stay: FloridaKeysResorts.com

Not sure where to stay in the Florida Keys? That's exactly the problem FloridaKeysResorts.com was built to solve.

The site works as an independent answer engine for where to stay across all five Keys regions — Key West, Islamorada, Marathon, Key Largo, and the Lower Keys. There are no paid placements and no sponsored rankings, just honest, data-driven guidance matched to your trip style.

The logic is simple: Key West for first-timers and nightlife. Marathon for families. Islamorada for couples and upscale dining. Key Largo for diving and reef access. The Lower Keys for quiet escapes and nature. Each region guide walks you through the real decision factors — walkability, dining, nightlife, diving access, and family appeal — so you land in the right place before you ever book a room.

The site also tracks limited-time resort deals, seasonal packages, and direct booking specials that aren't widely advertised, and sends them straight to subscribers.

Find your perfect Keys stay →

🧩 Deep Dive

Jimmy Buffett's Hidden Key West: The Night "Margaritaville" Was Born

When Jimmy Buffett arrived in Key West at the end of 1971, he was just a "young Nashville folk gypsy" looking for a gig. He found his first island home at Crazy Ophelia's Café, located at 615 Duval Street (where Antonia's restaurant stands today).

Opened in December 1971 by John J. Young and Hank Villate, Crazy Ophelia's was more than just a music venue. It was a cultural hub for the island's counterculture, offering food, free medical care, drug counseling, and job placement. On January 27, 1972, Buffett played one of his very first Key West shows there.

But the most legendary story from Crazy Ophelia's involves Buffett's signature anthem. One evening, while driving down from Miami for a gig at the café, Buffett got stuck in a massive traffic jam on the Seven Mile Bridge because a vehicle had broken down ahead. Sitting in his car, staring out at the water, he used the unexpected delay to pen the final verses of "Margaritaville." He debuted the completed song that very night on the stage at Crazy Ophelia's.

Buffett found inspiration in other quiet corners of the island, too. In a handwritten letter dated October 22, 1989, he thanked the Monroe County Library for being his sanctuary. "When I first moved to Key West and spent the summers in town, this library was a place to pass the days browsing and reading about the old days on this island for songs that I would eventually write," he wrote. "Thanks for keeping me cool in those hot happy summers not so long ago and being my office before I could afford one."

In 1986, Buffett leased an old ice house near the shrimp docks in the Key West Historic Seaport and transformed it into Shrimpboat Sound Recording Studio. He recorded his Hot Water album there in 1987, and the studio later hosted legends like Alan Jackson, Zac Brown, and Kenny Chesney.

Today, you can still walk past the building at 615 Duval Street or stroll by Shrimpboat Sound at the seaport. They are quiet reminders of the days when a young folk singer found his voice, his office, and his lost shaker of salt on a little island at the end of the road.

🕰️ Lore & Legends

Theater of the Sea: Born from a Railroad Quarry

In 1905, Henry Flagler's crews began blasting massive blocks of coral rock from Windley Key in Islamorada to build the Over-Sea Railroad. The excavation left behind deep, jagged quarry holes. When the devastating 1935 Labor Day Hurricane destroyed the railroad, those quarries flooded with seawater.

Five years later, a tourist from Atlanta noticed the flooded roadside quarries were teeming with colorful parrot fish. He told his employer, P.F. "Bud" McKenney, who drove down to see it for himself. McKenney had a wild vision: he wanted to turn the flooded railroad quarry into a marine park.

Bud and his wife Martha sold their ice cream parlors in Atlanta and moved to Tavernier. In 1946, they opened Theater of the Sea — making it the second oldest marine park in the world. They hired a local fisherman named Milton Santini to transport their first four dolphins. Admission was $1.50 for adults and 55 cents for kids.

The park quickly became famous for its intimate, up-close encounters. Two dolphins, Jeannie and Buttons, became national stars. Buttons was known as the "World's Champion Jumping Porpoise," leaping 20 feet into the air to snatch fish from a tower. The park even featured the world's only boat propelled by dolphins. Presidents Dwight D. Eisenhower and Harry S. Truman both visited, and NBC's Today Show broadcast live from the quarry.

In 1960, Hurricane Donna slammed into the Keys with a 13-foot storm surge, nearly destroying the facility. But McKenney refused to quit. He dug out new pools and expanded the habitat to hold 12 million gallons of water, creating what was then the "World's Largest Outdoor Aquarium."

Today, 80 years after it opened, Theater of the Sea is still operating on those same 17 acres in Islamorada. It remains family-owned, a living testament to the resilience of the Keys — and a beautiful example of how a scar left by a railroad was transformed into a sanctuary for the sea.

✅ Trivia Answer

Nobody could find it.

In 1972, locals put together a time capsule filled with personal mementos, books, and letters from residents — including letters from President Richard Nixon and Governor Reubin Askew. The plan was to open it in 2122 for the island's tricentennial.

When the bicentennial committee started planning for Key West's 200th birthday in 2022, they tried to locate the 1972 capsule. Newspaper stories from the time described it as being buried in a new development called "Old Town Square." The problem? Fifty years later, no such place exists.

Despite extensive searching by local historians, the time capsule remains lost to this day. To ensure history doesn't repeat itself, the committee built a new granite time capsule for the 2022 bicentennial — and placed it above ground at Mallory Square.

Until next week, keep your windows down and your watch off.— The Florida Keys Road Trip Team

Smart starts here.

You don't have to read everything — just the right thing. 1440's daily newsletter distills the day's biggest stories from 100+ sources into one quick, 5-minute read. It's the fastest way to stay sharp, sound informed, and actually understand what's happening in the world. Join 4.5 million readers who start their day the smart way.

Join for free today!