The man who mentored Jimmy Buffett...

...and why he was Key West's biggest star for 50 years.

Author

Florida Keys Road Trip
June 16, 2026

Hey Keys lovers! 

If you felt the ground shake last Monday, you weren't crazy. A 6.1 magnitude earthquake off the coast of Cuba sent tremors all the way up the island chain — a surreal experience for a place that usually only worries about wind and water.

This week, we are looking at a 22-pound silver bar just pulled from the ocean floor, a 1914 turf war over sea sponges that ended in dynamite, and the legendary piano player who gave Jimmy Buffett his start.

Was this forwarded to you? Sign up at FloridaKeysRoadTrip.com to get on Keys Time every week — it's free!

❓ KEYS TRIVIA
What was legendary treasure hunter Mel Fisher's famous daily motto during his 16-year search for the Spanish galleon Nuestra Señora de Atocha?

Answer at the bottom of the newsletter.

📣 THE MILE MARKER ROUNDUP

Earthquake Shakes the Keys: A 6.1 magnitude earthquake struck off the coast of Cuba near Mantua on Monday afternoon, June 8. Shaking was felt across South Florida, including the Florida Keys. While buildings were evacuated in Miami, no damage was reported in the Keys — just a lot of confused locals wondering why their ceiling fans were swaying. https://www.mysuncoast.com/2026/06/08/61-magnitude-earthquake-off-cuba-felt-across-florida/

Summer Solstice Celebration: The second annual 14-day festival is happening now at Mallory Square in Key West, featuring acrobats, illusionists, wish banners, and flower-crown making. It culminates on June 21 with a ticketed World Food Experience showcasing sample-sized dishes from local restaurants. If you are in Key West this week, this is worth your evening. https://www.keywestchamber.org/latest-community-news/key-wests-summer-solstice-celebration-2026-has-officially-launched

First Atocha Silver Bar Since 1999: Mel Fisher's treasure hunters just pulled a 22-pound silver bar from the wreck of the Atocha. Captain Drake Nicholas spotted the bar, struck it with a knife, and saw the telltale markings. The bar is worth an estimated $100,000 — and it is the first silver bar recovered from the site in 27 years. https://boingboing.net/2026/06/12/mel-fishers-treasure-hunters-find-another-chunk-of-atocha-silver.html

Barracuda Bust: FWC officers caught two Key West men with 56 barracuda — far exceeding the two-per-person daily bag limit. While barracuda are not commonly targeted for food, strict limits exist to protect the reef ecosystem. The men face fines and potential criminal charges. https://keysweekly.com/42/into-the-teeth-of-the-law-key-west-men-busted-with-56-baracuda/

🌴 HURRICANE SEASON SURVIVAL GUIDE FOR KEYS VISITORS


Here is what you actually need to know before you book.

Hurricane season officially started June 1. If you are visiting the Florida Keys between now and November 30, a little preparation goes a long way. The Keys are resilient — but they are also a chain of islands connected by a single road, and that changes everything when a storm approaches.

First, the Keys have mandatory evacuation zones, and visitors are always ordered to evacuate first — typically 48 to 72 hours before residents. If an order is issued, you must leave. There is no waiting it out.

Second, buy travel insurance before your trip. Standard hotel cancellation policies will not cover you unless there is an official evacuation order in place.

Third, download the Monroe County Emergency app for real-time alerts the moment you arrive.

The good news: the Keys have weathered every storm for over a century. The infrastructure is built for it. A little preparation means you can book your trip with confidence and enjoy every minute of it.

Read the official Monroe County Emergency Management guide here → https://www.monroecounty-fl.gov/897/Emergency-Management

🧩 COFFEE BUTLER: KEY WEST'S BIGGEST STAR BEFORE BUFFETT


For 50 years, he was the soundtrack of the island. Most visitors have never heard his name.

Today, when you want to see a live outdoor concert in Key West, you head to the Truman Waterfront and the Coffee Butler Amphitheater. But unless you lived in the Keys before 2005, you might not know who Coffee Butler was — or why his name is on the most important music venue in the city.

He was born Lofton Butler in 1928 in Bahama Village, the historic African-American neighborhood at the heart of Old Town Key West. His friends mispronounced "Loffy" so often and so consistently that it simply became "Coffee," and the name stuck for the rest of his life.

Coffee played baseball in the Florida-Cuba League for the Palm Beach Rockets in the early 1950s, but music was always his calling. He performed with his father's band, Duke and the Royal Aces, before forming his own group, Coffee and the Cups. For 50 years, he was the premier entertainer in Key West — often called the Louis Armstrong of the island.

He played for President Harry Truman at the Little White House. He performed for Tennessee Williams and Tallulah Bankhead. When a hurricane forced the Beatles' plane to make an emergency landing in the Keys, Coffee played for them, too.

For years, his signature gig was at Howie's Lounge, where his grand piano sat on a tiny stage in the front window facing the street. In the early 1970s, Jerry Jeff Walker and a young, largely unknown Jimmy Buffett would hang out at the bar. Buffett had been playing the Chart Room and the Snake Pit mostly for tips while working a day job on a fishing boat.

Coffee took Buffett under his wing. He let the young singer take the stage during his breaks, introduced him around, and eventually helped him secure paying gigs. It was a mentorship that helped launch a career that would define Key West's modern identity for the next 50 years.

Coffee Butler passed away in 2022 at the age of 93. His name is still in lights at the amphitheater — a permanent reminder of the man who provided the soundtrack to Key West long before anyone had heard of cheeseburgers in paradise.

🏴‍☠️ THE SPONGE WARS: THE DAY KEY WEST HARBOR EXPLODED


A 1914 turf war over sea sponges ended with dynamite, pistols, and a relocation that changed Florida forever.

In the mid-1800s, Key West was the sponge capital of the world. Local "Conch" spongers worked the shallow flats in small skiffs, leaning over the gunwales with glass-bottom buckets and 20-foot poles to hook sponges from the seafloor. It was slow, skilled work — and it was the backbone of the local economy.

Then the Greeks arrived.

Greek spongers brought hard-hat diving gear and 50-pound metal boots, allowing them to walk the ocean floor and harvest four times as many sponges from depths the Conchs could not reach. The Conchs were furious, claiming the heavy boots crushed and destroyed the sponge beds that had sustained their families for generations.

The tension exploded on May 22, 1914. A mob of 500 Conchs descended on the Greek schooner Amelia in Key West harbor. The crew fled into a nearby store, where two women brandishing pistols held the mob at bay while the ship's captain attempted to row away — and was shot in the knee for his trouble.

That night, 25 armed men boarded the Amelia, robbed it, and blew it up with dynamite — with one crew member still aboard. Another Greek ship was attacked near the Marquesas Keys the same day.

The violence worked. In 1917, Florida passed a law prohibiting hard-hat diving for sponges in Keys waters. The Greek spongers relocated to the west coast of Florida, transforming Tarpon Springs into the new Sponge Capital of the World. The Key West sponge industry limped along for another two decades before a devastating blight in the 1940s wiped it out entirely.

✅ TRIVIA ANSWER


"Today's the day."

Every morning for 16 years, Mel Fisher told his crew those three words as they headed out to search the ocean floor off Key West for the Nuestra Señora de Atocha — a Spanish galleon that sank in a 1622 hurricane carrying an estimated $450 million in gold, silver, and emeralds.

On July 20, 1985, it finally was. His crew discovered the mother lode. And as this week's news proves, the ocean is still giving up the Atocha's secrets — one 22-pound silver bar at a time.

Bonus: The Mel Fisher Maritime Museum at 200 Greene Street in Key West displays gold bars, silver coins, and a 77-carat emerald cross recovered from the wreck. It is one of the most remarkable small museums in the country and well worth an hour of your trip.

Until next week, keep your windows down and your watch off.
The Florida Keys Road Trip Team

Keep your windows down and your watch off.
The Florida Keys Road Trip Team

A Better Way to Plan Where You Stay in the Florida Keys

If you’ve ever planned a trip to the Florida Keys, you know how it goes…

You open 15 tabs.
Scroll through endless lists.
And somehow feel less sure than when you started.

We built something to fix that.

It’s not a booking site.
It’s a decision engine.

It helps you figure out:

  • which part of the Keys fits your trip

  • what actually matters before you book

  • and where you’ll be happiest once you get there

Just the right answer for your trip.

If you’re planning a trip, or even thinking about one, start here:

Pique's Carrara Marine Collagen combines Type I + II marine collagen, biotin, and pearl powder for smoother skin, stronger hair, and real structural resilience - made for your morning ritual. Shop Carrara Now.