- Florida Keys Road Trip
- Posts
- A Doctor, a Mattress Needle and a Tarpon Named Scarface
A Doctor, a Mattress Needle and a Tarpon Named Scarface
...and why the busiest dock at MM 77.5 started with one hurt fish.
Make connection part of your routine.

Take ZOLEO on your next hike for messaging and “I’m OK” check-in messages beyond cell coverage. Save 20% on a regularly priced ZOLEO Satellite Communicator with code STAYCONNECTED20.
Not valid on sale-priced devices or with other discounts. Valid outside promotional sale periods.
Florida Keys Road Trip | Tuesday, November 18, 2026
Hey Keys lovers!
Thanksgiving is eight days away, and the Keys are in that sweet spot right before the holiday rush.
Key West rolls out a film festival tomorrow, the Sheriff's Animal Farm opens its gates Sunday, and the boats along the Historic Seaport start lighting up next Wednesday.
And up in Islamorada, a dock full of fish is still celebrating a fifty-year-old rescue.
Was this forwarded to you? Sign up here to get Florida Keys Road Trip every week. It's free.
💰 Deals This Week
Coconut Palm Inn, Tavernier Up to 35% off fall stays, if you book dates before the end of the year. Veterans, military, teachers and first responders can get up to 15% off. → See the deal
Banana Bay Resort & Marina, Marathon 20% off stays of three nights or more. Here for your birthday week? Your second night is a dollar. → See the deal
The Islands of Islamorada Book a three-night villa stay at least a week ahead and get a $500 credit toward a private sunset charter for up to six. Florida residents can also save up to 18%. → See the deal
Rates and dates depend on availability, so check before you book.
Got a Keys deal for our readers? Reply to this email.
❓ Keys Trivia
A tarpon can do something most fish cannot.
It can come up to the surface and gulp air.
True or false?
Answer at the bottom.
📣 The Mile Marker Roundup
Wednesday to Sunday, Nov. 18 to 22: Key West Film Festival, 15th year, opening with Paper Tiger. → See the schedule
Thursday, Nov. 19: Key West Farmers Market, 1 to 6 p.m., Truman Waterfront Park. Fruit, bread and people watching. → Get directions
Sunday, Nov. 22: Sheriff's Animal Farm open house, 1 to 3 p.m., Stock Island. Free. Rescued animals living under a jail, which is about the most Key West sentence we've ever written. → Get directions
Wednesday, Nov. 25: The "Bight Before Christmas" Walk of Lights, 6:30 to 10:30 p.m., Historic Seaport. Free. → Get directions
🌴 Partner Spotlight
The Islands of Islamorada
Waterfront villas and suites in Islamorada, a few minutes up the road from the tarpon at Robbie's.
The honest detail: this is a stay-put kind of place. Boats, sandbars, a tiki bar. If you need nightlife, Key West is two hours south.
For a slow Thanksgiving week by the water, it is hard to beat.
🧩 Deep Dive: The Fish That Started It All
How one hurt tarpon turned Robbie's of Islamorada into one of the most famous stops on US-1
Mile Marker 77.5, Islamorada
In 1976, a man named Robbie Reckwerdt drove across the state from Naples and signed a lease on an old fishing camp on Lower Matecumbe.
Not long after, he found a tarpon floundering in the shallows by his dock.
He figured it was stuck. He lifted it out of the water, and that's when he saw it. The right side of the fish's jaw was torn open.
Most people would have let it go, or let nature handle it. Robbie put it in a shrimp tank with plenty of oxygen and picked up the phone.
He called a local doctor. Not a veterinarian. A people doctor, Doc Roach.
Doc Roach came over and stitched the jaw closed, using his wife's mattress needles and twine. As far as anybody knows, it was the first tarpon ever to get stitches.
Then came the hard part. For several days, Robbie and his wife, Mona, force-fed the fish. It started gaining weight. It started looking like a fish that might make it.
They named it Scarface.
About six months later, they let it go.
And Scarface came back.
He kept showing up at the dock, looking for a handout. Sometimes he brought a friend. Then more tarpon started showing up, and they kept showing up, and fifty years later they still do.
That is how a fishing camp became one of the most famous stops in the Keys.
What it's like now
Today Robbie's is a whole little world at Mile Marker 77.5. There's a marina, charters, a glass-bottom boat, a row of shops, and the Hungry Tarpon restaurant, which takes its name straight from the story.
But the dock is still the reason people pull over.
You buy a bucket of baitfish, walk out on the dock, and lean over the rail. The water looks calm. Then a tarpon the length of a grown man comes up out of it and takes the fish right out of your hand.
People scream. Every time.
A few tips from people who have done it:
Hold the fish low and let go fast. Tarpon have rough, sandpaper mouths. They don't bite, but they don't ask nicely either.
Watch the pelicans. They know exactly what's in your bucket, and they are faster than you.
Grab a table at the Hungry Tarpon after. It's right on the water, so you can keep watching the feeding while you eat.
Robbie's is open every day, 7 a.m. to 9 p.m. Morning and late afternoon tend to be calmer than midday.
Before Robbie's
The land has its own story. Before Robbie took it over, it was the Starck Fishing Camp, run by Buck and Ruth Starck, who arrived on Lower Matecumbe in 1946 and were called the island's first permanent residents. They worked out of an old Key lime packing house they moved onto the property, and they lived on that island for the rest of their lives.
The Reckwerdt family bought the property from the Starcks in 2012. Robbie's son, Michael, runs it today.
Plan your stop
Robbie's of Islamorada is at Mile Marker 77.5 on US-1, on Lower Matecumbe Key.
🍹 Four Things We'd Tell a Friend
Feed the tarpon at Robbie's, and hold on. Buy a bucket, walk the dock, dangle the fish low. Watch out for the pelicans. They are faster than you. → Get directions
Make your Thanksgiving dinner reservation today. Waterfront tables go first, and next week is too late. → Find a stay nearby
Take the kids to the Animal Farm on Sunday. Free, odd and wonderful. Sloths have been known to make appearances. → Get directions
Walk the Seaport the night before Thanksgiving. The boats light up, the bars are full and nobody is in a hurry. → Get directions
🕰️ Lore & Legends
Before Robbie's, the land was the Starck Fishing Camp.
Buck and Ruth Starck bought 17 acres on Lower Matecumbe in 1946 and were called the island's first permanent residents. They moved an old Key lime packing house onto the property to work out of while they built their homes.
They lived on that island the rest of their lives.
In 2010 they died within days of each other, still on Lower Matecumbe.
✅ Trivia Answer
True.
Tarpon can gulp air at the surface and use it to breathe, which lets them live in warm, still water that would suffocate most fish. Watch the water at Robbie's long enough and you'll see one roll up for a breath.
Hit reply and tell us: what was the first thing you ever fed off a dock in the Keys? We read every one.
Until next week, keep your windows down and your watch off.
The Florida Keys Road Trip Team