10 Places in the Keys You’ll Tell Stories About Forever

Every Island Is a Story Waiting to Be Told

There are vacations — and then there are Florida Keys road trips. The kind of trips where the map matters less than the mile markers, and the best stops are the ones you weren’t planning for. Whether you’re watching a storm roll across the Gulf from a hammock, or talking to a bartender who swears Hemingway once stole his cousin’s boat — this place gets under your skin.

So we pulled together the 10 places you absolutely have to visit while you’re here. Not the most commercial. Not the most polished. But the ones where you’ll feel something. And months from now, when someone asks how your trip was, these are the stories you’ll tell.

1. Key West: The End of the Road, the Start of Something Weird

You don’t visit Key West. You fall into it like a dream — part history lesson, part party, part beautiful fever dream involving roosters, rum, and poetry.

Spend the morning with six-toed cats at the Ernest Hemingway Home, the afternoon sipping something frozen on Duval Street, and the evening watching the sun melt behind Mallory Square to the sound of steel drums and street performers juggling fire.

📍 What You’ll Tell People: “There was a drag queen in a shoe drop at midnight, and I swear a parrot blessed my mojito.”

2. Key Largo: Where the Ocean’s the Main Attraction

Key Largo is for those who prefer their adventures underwater. This is the Dive Capital of the Continental U.S., and you’ll feel it in your bones the first time you drop into the reef and see the coral towers sway.

At John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park, you can snorkel, paddle, or take a glass-bottom boat tour to see the famous Christ of the Deep statue. Then grab some conch fritters and let your hair dry salty in the breeze.

📍 What You’ll Tell People: “I met a barracuda named Bob. We had a moment.”

3. Islamorada: Where the Fish Bite and the Drinks Flow

Half luxury, half salty legend, Islamorada is a village of six islands with a passion for fishing and fine sunsets. Stop by Robbie’s Marina to hand-feed tarpon the size of your cousin’s kayak. Or just settle in at a beach bar with your feet in the sand and let the day drift by.

With its boutique resorts and clear waters, this is where the real Keys magic happens — slow, sweet, and sun-drenched.

📍 What You’ll Tell People: “A fish stole my bait and my pride. I had to chase it with a margarita.”

4. Marathon: The Laid-Back Heart of the Keys

Marathon is where people go when they want it all — beaches, boats, and a touch of old Florida warmth. It’s family-friendly but not boring, scenic but never showy.

Visit the Turtle Hospital to meet rehabbed sea turtles with names like Bubble Butt and Mr. T. Or rent a boat, hit the water, and cruise the coast until you find your own private sandbar.

📍 What You’ll Tell People: “We stayed three nights. Then five. Then we looked at real estate.”

5. Seven Mile Bridge: The Road You’ll Never Forget

Driving this bridge feels like flying. Just water to the left, water to the right, and you — suspended over the sea.

Park near the pedestrian path and walk part of the Old Seven Mile Bridge to see Fred the Tree, the little palm growing defiantly out of concrete. A roadside legend and a metaphor, depending how your week’s going.

📍 What You’ll Tell People: “I’ve never cried on a bridge before. Until now.”

6. Bahia Honda State Park: The Best Beach You’ve Never Heard Of

No crowds. No condos. Just real-deal sand, teal-blue water, and a breeze so steady it feels scripted.

Climb the short trail to the old railroad bridge for a sweeping view of the Keys, or dive into one of the best swimming beaches in Florida. Pack a cooler and stay a while — you’ll wish you had more time.

📍 What You’ll Tell People: “I don’t even like the beach. But I liked this beach.”

7. Dry Tortugas National Park: The Keys’ Best Kept Secret

Only accessible by ferry or seaplane, this 19th-century fort surrounded by turquoise water feels like something out of a pirate story.

Snorkel the moat wall. Tour Fort Jefferson, built with over 16 million bricks. Then lay back on the sand and let the silence wrap around you like a warm towel. No Wi-Fi. No cars. No problem.

📍 What You’ll Tell People: “It was like being shipwrecked — but with better food.”

8. Big Pine Key: Where the Wild Things Are

If the rest of the Keys are parties, Big Pine is a deep breath. It’s quiet. It’s wild. And it’s where the endangered Key deer roam freely through neighborhoods and backroads.

Take a drive around No Name Key, watch the stars from a canal dock, or grab a drink at No Name Pub, where the ceiling’s covered in dollar bills and the stories are always free.

📍 What You’ll Tell People: “I met a deer at the gas station. He didn’t seem impressed.”

9. The Lower Keys: Where the Keys Go to Relax

No cruise ships. No chain restaurants. Just mangroves, canals, and sleepy charm. This is old-school Keys living — kayak through the backcountry, fish the flats, or just swing in a hammock and forget what day it is.

Perfect for couples, solo wanderers, or anyone who wants to go off the radar without going off the map.

📍 What You’ll Tell People: “I saw maybe 12 people in two days. And it was glorious.”

10. Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary: The Soul of the Sea

This sanctuary protects 3,800 square miles of reef, seagrass, and mangrove — the entire underwater heart of the Keys. Snorkel it, dive it, or float above it in awe.

It’s home to everything from sea turtles to reef sharks to rainbow parrotfish. And it's the reason this place still feels wild.

📍 What You’ll Tell People: “I snorkeled next to a barracuda and didn’t scream. Growth.”

🌅 Final Thought From the Road

You’ll forget your towel. You’ll lose your sunglasses. But you’ll remember these places.

The Keys don’t just offer destinations — they offer moments. And if you’re lucky, those moments turn into the kind of stories you’ll be telling for years — under porches, over cocktails, or to anyone who says, “So what’s Florida really like?”

See you out there,
The FloridaKeysRoadTrip.com crew

Seeking impartial news? Meet 1440.

Every day, 3.5 million readers turn to 1440 for their factual news. We sift through 100+ sources to bring you a complete summary of politics, global events, business, and culture, all in a brief 5-minute email. Enjoy an impartial news experience.

Join for free today!